The dark forces of football oligarchy are ganging up on little Chester City but it looks like one rule for the minnows, another for the big clubs. The FA have ordered Stephen Vaughan, Chester’s owner and main financial prop to sell his shareholding because he is not a “fit and proper person” to be involved in running a football club.
Considering some of the people who have owned and run football clubs, Ken Bates, Fat Stan Flashman, the former Thai Prime Minister who bought Man. City while awaiting trial for every crime on the statute book, Alan Sugar and a soft porn millionaire to name but a few, you might well ask “What has Vaughan does that is so terrible?”
Apart from owning a small club with no clout he has only been involved in a VAT fraud. Hasn’t everyone? Yes but not everyone got caught. Perhaps that is the problem, anybody who is not smart and slippery enough to outwit the VATman cannot possibly be allowed to run a football club.
Meanwhile, up in the Premier League the Football Thought police have no such problem. They cannot charge the owner of Birmingham City with not being a fit and proper person because they cannot find out who really owns the club. Officially the owner is the geezerish sounding Carson Yeung but it seems Mr. Yeung is only a front man. Due to the opacity of Birmingham’s financial structure nobody can see who is behind him. The major shareholders are two companies whose registered offices are adjacent pigeon holes in a mail drop n the British Virgin Islands.
As the companies do not appear to have any assets other than Birmingham City, no discernible business activities and no turnover or financial dealings the Birmingham situation makes Steve Vaughan’s little VAT scam look innocuous. But then Chester are an easier bite for a toothless watchdog.
If we think of all the scandals that have tainted football however this prim approach to trivial misdemeanours looks even more out of place.
Manchester United are the biggest but not the only Premier League side bought with their own money, the Galser family putting up nothing except their acquaintance with some dodgy financiers.
The Carlos Tevez transfer saga in which it finally emerged Tevez was owned by a sports agency who theoretically could peddle his services to the highest bidder on a week by week basis.
The outrageous relegation of Sheffield United when West Ham should have been thrown out of the league for their involvement in the Tevez affair.
Those are big ones but don't forget the ever changing strip scams, big match ticket marketing, roasting, alleged match fixing, bungs to referees to facilitate bouts of temporary blindness during Hand Of God related incidents and the general financial dodginess of most clubs. If the laws governing commerce were applied the majority of teams would be compulsorily wound up as they are insolvent. In view of all that you just have to wonder who would be considered a fit and proper person to run a club? The Kray Twins, Bernie Madoff, Ronnie Biggs, Jeffery Archer, Don Vito Berlusconi, Robert Mugabe, Hazel Blears?



